Got a Bad Review? The Best Defense is a Good Offense!

Lisa Dye • July 26, 2019

Got a Bad Review? The Best Defense Is a Good Offense!

Let me guess. You got a HORRIBLE review from a ticked off customer, and you’re trying to make it go away. 


First things first: Breathe! We know that your business is your baby, and you worked hard to get it to where it is today. 


Don’t worry. Customer attacks happen to the best of us. As tempting as it might be to punch a wall, don’t lose your cool. We can fix this. 


I can’t promise you that Google or the third party review site will take it down, but I’ll tell you one thing: the BEST defense is a GOOD offense!

Higher Ratings Equal Higher Rankings

As a local business, local SEO plays a huge role in the average local marketing strategy. It’s a big deal, because it can maximize your visibility on some big-time platforms and directories, including:


Facebook Local

YellowPages

Healthgrades


It also increases your exposure on smaller directories you might not know about, and as you know, you can never have too much exposure. 


Reviews are just as important to your local SEO strategy as local SEO is to your overall marketing strategy. 


The higher your ratings, the higher your business will appear in search queries relating to your product or service offerings.

Plot Twist: Bad Reviews Aren’t Always a Bad Thing

All publicity is good publicity, including bad reviews.


The thing is, you can learn a lot from a bad review. Instead of seeing it as a negative, look at it as an opportunity to grow from past mistakes. 


There’s no such thing as a perfect business. And guess what? People realize it. They’ll give businesses the grace to redeem themselves and right their wrongs. Take advantage of that.



One bad review won’t put you out of business. If you approach it with the right attitude, the person who wrote the review might have a change of heart. 


Reviewers—in some cases—are willing to update, or take down a review when their issues have been resolved. 


That’s going to require some damage control on your part (or your online reputation management team). 


We’ve put together a roundup of best practices to follow when handling a bad review.

Step #1: Respond

If you plan on ignoring that bad review like it’s not there, you might want to rethink your strategy. 


They say that no response is a response. Your approach to a bad review is a direct reflection of your approach to conflict resolution.


By pretending that it doesn’t exist, it partially represents your attitude towards customer satisfaction.


That’s why it’s just best to respond. Your team needs to acknowledge their awareness of that customer’s issue, and reassure the customer that they’d like to turn the situation around for the better. 


Most importantly, you’ll want to encourage the reviewer to elaborate on the matter with your team.


Don’t respond with the intention of dismissing the reviewer’s claim. Placing the blame on the customer is not a good look. Make it clear that your team comes in peace. 


Apologize for their experience (even if the allegations sound false), and leave your email address or phone number in the response to open up the dialogue. 


Don’t let too much time go by before you respond. Also, don’t make the response longer than it has to be. A short and prompt reply would be your best bet.


The goals of your response are to a) take the conversation offline, and b) gather more information about the situation.


Your response is an important step of the process, because the information will help you determine the next big question. 

Step #2: Make Sure That the Feedback Is Legitimate

Every once in a while, there’s a possibility you might come across a fake review.


Fake reviews are a ploy that competitors and angry employees use to ruin your reputation. 


A review also counts as fake when the person who wrote it has never purchased your products or services.


For every bad review you receive, you’ll want to investigate the issue to make sure that reviewer is an actual customer. 


If it’s a fake review, you can flag it as such and request that it be taken down. 


Oftentimes, that’s the ONLY reason that the moderators of the review site will remove a review (unless the reviewer takes it down).

Step 3: Put On Your Detective Hat

If you can confirm that the review is real, take immediate action to get your facts straight about that customer or patient. 


Do some digging to find out more about their purchase history, their previous dates of contact, and the date and time that they proclaimed to have the bad experience.

This information can unlock some important clues pertaining to your investigation. 


Once you have the information you need, you can use your best judgment on how to rectify the issue and find a happy medium with that customer.

When In Doubt, Drown Out the Bad with the Good!

Reviews are full of surprises. You don’t always know what you’re going to get or when you’re going to get them.


When you receive a bad review, remember that it’s not the end of the world. Just don’t have too many at once. That can have a damaging impact on your reputation.


The best thing you can do is to drown out the bad reviews with positive ones. Believe me, it works. 


Bad reviews pop up when you least expect it, so it’s important that you NEVER let your guard down.


Stay vigilant in your efforts to earn new reviews. Make review solicitation an ongoing task by incorporating it into your email (or SMS) marketing strategy.


One thing you can do is, create a review request for your customers in the form of an electronic survey. The shorter the survey, the better! 


I’ll tell you why. The average customer has a short attention span . You will bore them to death with a long, drawn-out survey.


Try to keep the questions at a maximum of 10. Reserve one question of the survey for general feedback, and give your customers enough space to write a paragraph-length response for that question. 


Automated software can push out that one particular response to your website, and to other third-party review sites. 


And voilà, there goes your review strategy. With enough survey responses, you can hit the review jackpot.


Don’t worry about the reviews being good or bad. With a solid online reputation management strategy, you can pivot your responses like a pro as the reviews come. 

Get Your Defense Team In Place

Review solicitation doesn’t have to be a chore that you have to add to your never-ending to-do list. 


Our team will gladly step in as your task force to start the initiative, and to keep it going. 


We offer solutions that are designed to keep the reviews rolling in, ensuring that solicitation is one less thing you have to worry about. 


If there’s one thing you don’t have to question, it’s the fact that we’ve got your back here at The Infinity Group. We’re prepared to do what it takes to protect your good name. Contact us today to find out more about our online reputation management services .

Person making the right decision. Choosing an item with a green checkmark over those with red x's.
October 6, 2025
Not all SEO is the same. Learn how to choose the right medical SEO services for your practice, what to look for, and what red flags to avoid
Doctor looking at his analytics to determine the value of his SEO investment
October 5, 2025
Medical SEO services take time, but they pay off for years. Learn why SEO is a smart long-term investment for doctors who want steady patient growth.
Doctor visiting with elderly patient
October 4, 2025
Local SEO helps doctors show up when patients search “near me.” Learn how local SEO works and why it’s one of the most powerful tools for attracting new patients.
Doctor looking at his medical practice's SEO results
October 3, 2025
Discover the top medical SEO services doctors need to attract more patients. Learn why local SEO, content, and website optimization matter most.
Smiling doctor
October 2, 2025
Learn what medical SEO services include, why they matter for doctors, and how they help healthcare practices attract patients and grow online.
Question marks
October 1, 2025
Hiring a medical SEO agency? Ask these key questions first to avoid red flags, choose the right partner, and ensure your practice gets real results.
Person at home on the sofa looking for a doctor on google or asking questions of an AI chatbot
September 30, 2025
Discover how a medical SEO agency helps doctors attract more patients. Learn how SEO improves visibility, builds trust, and grows your practice long-term.
Person on laptop working on SEO for doctors
September 29, 2025
Not all SEO is the same. Learn the difference between a medical SEO agency and a general SEO agency, and why doctors need specialized strategies to grow online.
SEO expert at a digital marketing agency reviewing analytics
September 28, 2025
Wondering what a medical SEO agency actually does? Learn what to expect, from website optimization to content and local SEO, and how it helps doctors grow online.
SEO experts reviewing a medical website at a digital marketing agency
September 27, 2025
A medical SEO agency helps doctors get found online. Learn why specialized SEO matters, how it works, and why it’s key to attracting new patients.